Weekly Deal Analysis - Auctions

← This week’s auction list

This is an archived week, published in full and free to everyone. Auctions listed here have already been held. For the current week, see this week’s analysis.

Auction dates: Sep 18, 2026 · 1 of 55 auctions cleared the screen

Our read on this week’s 55 auctions: which are worth your Friday, what we think each is worth finished, and the most we would bid.

Trustee auctions

Public trustee sales on Sep 18, 2026. Facts are public record; the numbers are our opinion.

Cleared the screen

CLEARED

305 SE Grant St, Pullman, WA 99163 Map ↗

County
Whitman
Sale date
September 18, 2026
Opening bid
$150,208
Sale number
24-01390WA

Clears by a few thousand dollars on an automated value we cannot check locally

Our value, finished
$410,000
Repairs, estimated
$131,000
Our maximum bid
$156,000

Four bedrooms, three baths, about 2,010 square feet, built in 1962, in Pullman. The opening bid is about $150,000 and our ceiling about $156,000, so the room is a few thousand dollars on rounded numbers and under $10,000 any way you cut it.

We have no benchmark of our own in Whitman County, so the finished value rests entirely on an automated estimate of what the house is worth today. We then subtract a full repair budget from it, which is conservative if the house needs real work and simply wrong if the estimate is. On a margin this small, the comps decide it, and a WSU town has a rental market that a flip model ignores entirely. If you are a landlord rather than a flipper this may be a better property than our numbers suggest. If you are a flipper, the room is not there.

Before you bid

  • Finished value is an automated estimate, not comps - Whitman County has no benchmark in our model and the whole number rests on it
  • Room under $10,000 - one surprise on title or repairs erases it
  • Lien position unverified - title search before bidding
  • No interior access, so the repair figure assumes worst case
  • Assume occupied until proven otherwise - budget cash-for-keys and a timeline

Watching - no opening bid published yet

Trustees often post the opening bid within days of the sale. These are the properties where we have done the work in advance, so you already know your ceiling if a number appears.

WATCHING

4000 23rd St SE, Puyallup, WA 98374 Map ↗

County
Pierce
Sale date
September 18, 2026
Opening bid
Not yet published
Sale number
25-77207
Our value, finished
$740,000
Our maximum bid
$355,000

Three bedrooms, three baths, about 2,500 square feet, built in 2018 in South Hill. Our two methods land within about ten percent of each other here, which makes this the best-supported ceiling on the list. No opening bid published as of Monday. On a house this new the repair budget is probably generous, which means the ceiling is probably conservative. If a bid posts under it, this is the one to spend your comp time on.

WATCHING

1439 E Mason Ave, Buckley, WA 98321 Map ↗

County
Pierce
Sale date
September 18, 2026
Opening bid
Not yet published
Sale number
141582-WA
Our value, finished
$630,000
Our maximum bid
$305,000

Three bed, three bath, about 2,100 square feet, built in 1975. Both of our methods agree within a few percent, so the ceiling is as solid as we can make it without going inside. No opening bid published yet.

WATCHING

20608 7th Ave Ct E, Spanaway, WA 98387 Map ↗

County
Pierce
Sale date
September 18, 2026
Opening bid
Not yet published
Sale number
WA-26-1033251-SW
Our value, finished
$615,000
Our maximum bid
$285,000

Five bedrooms, three baths, about 2,200 square feet, built in 2014. A newer house in a zip where our neighbourhood benchmark is one we have checked against sales. The two methods sit about fifteen percent apart, with the neighbourhood model the higher of the two; we have published it because it is the one built on this zip's actual sales, but comp it before you lean on the ceiling. No opening bid yet.

WATCHING

17233 SE 228th St, Kent, WA 98042 Map ↗

County
King
Sale date
September 18, 2026
Opening bid
Not yet published
Sale number
WA09000116-25
Our value, finished
$695,000
Our maximum bid
$353,000

Four bedrooms, two baths, about 2,040 square feet, built in 1930, in the Covington end of Kent. This is the Spanaway situation from last week in reverse: our two methods disagree by about a third, and this time it is the neighbourhood model that is the lower one. The most likely explanation is land. A 1930 house on a parcel of any size in that corridor can be worth a great deal more than the house alone, and a per-square-foot model prices the house alone. We have published the lower figure because it is the one we can defend from sales. If the parcel is large, the real ceiling is higher and this becomes the most interesting property of the week. Check the lot before anything else.

WATCHING

13612 Vail Rd SE, Yelm, WA 98597 Map ↗

County
Thurston
Sale date
September 18, 2026
Opening bid
Not yet published
Sale number
26-131036
Our value, finished
$580,000
Our maximum bid
$230,000

Three bed, three bath, about 2,190 square feet, built in 1970, on Vail Road outside Yelm. We have budgeted repairs here above our usual blind rate, about $80 a square foot rather than $65, because what we can see of the property points to heavier work than the typical fixer. The ceiling carries that. If the interior turns out better than we fear there is more room than the number shows; we would rather you find that out with a lower bid in hand than the other way round. No opening bid published yet.

WATCHING

7909 SW 248th St, Vashon, WA 98070 Map ↗

County
King
Sale date
September 18, 2026
Opening bid
Not yet published
Sale number
WA-25-1023826-RM
Our value, finished
$1,570,000
Our maximum bid
$790,000

The largest house on the list by a distance: six bedrooms, five baths, about 4,680 square feet, built in 2019 on Vashon Island. We have no neighbourhood benchmark on the island, so the finished value is an automated estimate and the repair budget on a house this new is almost certainly too high. Both of those push the ceiling down, which is the direction we prefer to be wrong in. If an opening bid appears anywhere near it, comps first, and remember the ferry: an island flip carries contractor and buyer-pool costs that a mainland one does not.

What we passed on

Free to everyone.

How we screen

On the market

We also run every fixer-condition house for sale in Pierce, King and Thurston counties through the same deal box. This week 68 of 213 cleared it. Read the listed fixers screen →

Previous weeks →

Reviewed by Charles Hays, Broker, September 14, 2026. Every figure below was checked by a licensed broker before this page served it. Charles Hays, Broker · Best Choice Realty.

What this is. A licensed Washington real estate broker’s opinion, published on a regular schedule to whoever asks for it. Values are broker price opinions, not appraisals, and may not be used in place of an appraisal for a loan or any federally related transaction.

What this is not. Reading this does not make you a client and creates no agency relationship. We are not representing you, we owe you no fiduciary duty, and nothing here is legal, tax, or investment advice. We may bid at these same auctions ourselves.

Verify before you bid. Auction facts come from public records and change without notice - sales are postponed and canceled routinely, sometimes the morning of. Confirm the sale, the opening bid, and above all the lien position with the trustee and a title search before bidding. Our repair and value figures are estimates formed without interior access.